Judge Allows Real Martha to Continue Defamation Lawsuit Against Netflix, Says ‘The Little Reindeer’ Isn’t a ‘True Story’

Fresh off impressive wins at the 76th Emmy Awards this month, Little reindeer he still has business to attend to. On Friday, September 27, the judge ruled that the real Marta, Fiona Harveyhe could continue his defamation suit against her Netflix after a series that failed to assure us in its opening credits that it was a “true story.” Created by Ryszard Gadd, Little reindeer is based on the personal experience of a comedian who was harassed by a “fan” while working in a London pub.

Netflix’s defamation lawsuit continues

Harvey, who was discovered by internet sleuths and fans of the show, also came forward after the series premiere. She spoke out against Gadd and streaming services, claiming they were lies against her. Series Little reindeer claims that Martha, played by Emmy winner Jessica Gunning, physically and sexually assaulted Gadd and was convicted of stalking.

In July, Netflix filed a motion to dismiss Harvey’s lawsuit. The events in the show and what happened in real life are different. Moreover, the opening line “This is a true story” leads viewers to believe that everything in this limited series is based on a true story. Judge Gary Klausner wrote: “There is a fundamental difference between stalking and a court conviction for stalking. Likewise, there are fundamental differences between inappropriate touching and sexual assault, and between pushing and gouging out another person’s eyes. Although the plaintiff claims that the actions are reprehensible, the defendants’ statements are of a lesser degree and may produce a different effect in the mind of the viewer.”

The judge also dismissed Harvey’s claims for negligence, infringement of her publicity rights and punitive damages. Harvey can continue his claim of intentional infliction of emotional distress because the show allows viewers to think that Martha’s and Harvey’s actions were the same.